Wooing our future science communicators – an instructor’s journey (part 2)

By Elizabeth Scherman

** Check out part 1 here **

A funny thing happened on the way to my Writing for the Sciences class. The class, created to “woo” reluctant STEM students to write, didn’t fill. Ironically, I’d proven my theory: young future STEM students often balk at writing. However, the Academic Talent Development Program (ATDP) at UC Berkeley’s Graduate School of Education did offer me an Analytical Writing class in its stead. I assigned many of the same types of writing assignments as I would have in the Writing for the Sciences class.

One of my high school-aged students – I’ll call him Arthur – took copious, almost painfully diagrammed notes of every class lecture. Like his classmates, he had been awarded entry into ATDP on his academic merit and motivation. I looked forward to reading his first essay. The second week of class, we did a timed write on the nature of villainy. Arthur froze. Not one single word made it onto the paper sitting before him. We met after class.

“Dr. Scherman,” he explained, “it’s not like doing math. With writing, there’s no right answer. I’m just going in circles trying out all of the possible solutions to the equation.”

ATDP students on their way to Doe Library.

ATDP students on their way to Doe Library.

Of course, there is no solution – because writing is not an equation. And Arthur is not alone. I called for STEM-bound students from my Analytical Writing class to share with me their past experiences and future fears about writing. I’ll let them speak for themselves:

From a future neurobiologist: “Writing about math is fairly simple because it’s logical. However, you can approach ‘English’ writing in so many ways that it’s difficult to fully know where to begin.”

From a future engineer: “Writing is supposed to be argumentative in nature, but we have no theorems or postulates to prove our claims.”

From a future coder: “In school and in the workplace, I fear that I will not be able to produce quality work in the given deadline.”

The last comment reflects a common thread: students squirm under deadlines and grade expectations. Arthur’s writing paralysis is not uncommon; perfect is often the enemy of the good. Many of my students confessed that they enjoy writing outside of school and away from the prying eyes of those who would assign grades and time limits.

“I will have to write more and more,” predicted one student. “This will be a challenge for me, to try not to be overwhelmed and stressed … also, I will have to learn to write faster.”

I gave my students permission – okay, I encouraged them – to write “terrible” first drafts (which were always comment-only) and to tackle in-class writes without the pressure of a grade. They received full points for trying. They did try. Lo and behold, much of their best writing was done under deadline in response to questions – “equations” – that do not have one correct answer.

When I told them this, they looked at me as if I’d gone round the bend.

Perhaps, I suggested, the correct answer to a writing equation is to do the best you can do in the time that you are given. Perhaps time constraints can be the very things that free us to err. And once we are allowed to err, the discovery begins.

About Elizabeth Scherman

Elizabeth SchermanElizabeth Leigh Scherman researches representations of divergent bodies in media as well as the rhetoric that accompanies such portrayals, whether in scientific literature, cinema, television, or other forms of popular culture.

She holds a Ph.D. in Communication from the University of Washington and is senior tenured faculty at Bates College in Tacoma, Washington. Her work has appeared in peer reviewed journals and edited collections, including Disability Studies Quarterly, The Galaxy is Rated G: Essays on Children’s Science Fiction Film and Television, edited by R.C. Neighbors and Sandy Rankin, The Worlds of Farscape, edited by Sherry Ginn, and an upcoming anthology, Tim Burton: Essays on the Films, edited by Johnson Cheu.

Scherman is developing original curriculum for teaching writing to students interested in STEM fields and will be teaching and initiating this curriculum at the University of California, Berkeley, Graduate School of Education, Academic Talent Development Program in the summer of 2016.

84 responses to “Wooing our future science communicators – an instructor’s journey (part 2)”

  1. http router asus com

    The default web address http router asus com lets you inside your Asus wireless router. Once you login to the Asus wireless router, you can configure or modify the wireless settings and many features of your router.

  2. Netgear Router Login

    For Netgear router login, open a web browser on a device connected to the Netgear wireless router. Type routerlogin.net in the address bar and you will reach the Netgear router login page.

  3. sportstotozone.com

    Hikayelerinizin çoğunu kontrol ediyorum ve oldukça zekice şeyler iddia edebilirim. Kesinlikle sitenizi yer imlerine ekleyeceğim.

  4. SLOTMACHINESITECOM

    HELLO, I THINK THIS IS AMONG THE MOST IMPORTANT INFORMATION TO ME! AND I AM GLAD TO READING YOUR ARTICLE. =)

  5. 토토365프로

    Please feel free to contact us if you have any inconvenience.

  6. youtube activation

    This article is truly informative and well-structured. I appreciate the detailed explanations and practical advice. Great job!

  7. rumble.com pair

    What an excellent article! The tips you provided are really helpful. I’ll definitely be using these in the future.

  8. disneyplus.com begin

    Thank you for this engaging post. Your tips and advice were practical and informative, making this a very useful read.

  9. rumble.com pair

    I’m grateful for this post! Your examples made complex concepts much easier to understand. It’s refreshing to see such practical advice. Keep up the fantastic work – I’ll be following closely.

  10. ibeautylabcokr18

    Excellent site you’ve got here. I appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!

  11. runarcherykr20

    Its a great pleasure to read this post. Awesome! Its full of information here

  12. homeplatekr

    I’m happy I read this. It is very well written, great Keep doing it Thanks

  13. mcafee.com/activate

    Wow, this post blew my mind! The details are so clear and concise. It’s exactly what I needed. Thanks for making this so awesome!

  14. disneyplus.com/begin

    Wonderful post! Your clear and concise writing style makes complex topics easily understandable. Looking forward to more of your work!

  15. www.kroger.com/feedback

    “Thank you for this excellent post. The insights you provided are both timely and relevant.”

  16. disneyplus.com login/begin

    Thank you for providing such a thorough and well-researched article. It was very informative and answered all my questions.

  17. drudge report 2024

    “This post was incredibly well-written and informative. I gained a lot of valuable insights that I can apply moving forward. Thank you for sharing your expertise!”

  18. www.hulu login/activate

    I appreciate the effort you put into this blog. The information is clear, concise, and incredibly helpful. Thanks for sharing!

  19. drudge report 2024

    “This post was incredibly well-written and informative. I gained a lot of valuable insights that I can apply moving forward. Thank you for sharing your expertise!”

  20. www.hulu login/activate

    Great insights! Your post really clarified things for me. Thanks for sharing such valuable information with the community!

  21. disneyplus.com login/begin

    Awesome! This article was exactly what I needed. Thank you for breaking down such a complex topic so clearly!

  22. www.kroger.com/feedback survey

    “Thank you for offering a fresh perspective on this topic. Your insights are always appreciated.”

  23. iforgot.apple.com website

    I truly appreciate the fresh perspective you provided. Thank you for the excellent content!

  24. www.homedepot.com/survey

    Thanks for highlighting such an important issue. Your perspective was enlightening.

  25. disneyplus.com login/begin

    Thank you for providing your insight; it adds depth to our conversation.

  26. disneyplus.com login/begin

    This post really cleared up my confusion on the topic. Thank you so much for providing such clear and detailed information.

  27. Disneyplus-loginbegin

    “Thanks for the really detailed article! It was super helpful and answered all my questions.”

  28. rumble app

    Thanks for this insightful post! It provided valuable information and I learned a lot. Keep up the great work!

  29. nyt connections game

    You can access your Asus wireless router by entering the default web address,connectionsgames.io. Once logged in, you’ll have the ability to configure and adjust various wireless settings and features of your router.

  30. iforgot.apple.com

    Thank you for delivering such useful information in a straightforward manner. It’s greatly appreciated!

  31. disneypluscombeginn

    This article is exceptionally informative and well-organized. I value the thorough explanations and practical tips provided. Excellent work!

  32. Whatsapp web

    Thrilled to see STEM Writing Resources for Learning (ScWRL) embracing WhatsApp Web as a tool for enhancing communication and collaboration! This will make accessing resources and sharing ideas much more convenient for students and educators alike. Excited to see how this integration will foster learning and innovation in the STEM community!

  33. hdnudesite

    you top site

  34. www.kroger.com/feedback

    Brilliant post! You’ve made a complicated subject so much easier to understand. Your blog is quickly becoming one of my go-to resources for learning new things. Thanks for the clear instructions!

  35. iforgot.apple.com website

    This article offered a lot of clarity. I really appreciate your effort.

  36. portal.office.com

    “I appreciate how you presented this information in a clear and concise manner. Thank you!”

  37. www.lowes.com/survey

    Thank you for this insightful post. It provided a fresh perspective that I found extremely valuable.

  38. www.lowes.com/survey

    Thanks for sharing your expertise on this topic. The examples you included made it much easier to understand.

  39. iforgot.apple.com website

    Thank you for addressing this issue so thoroughly. Your perspective is greatly appreciated.

  40. download rumble app

    What an awesome post! Your writing style is engaging and the information is very helpful. I learned a lot from this. Keep up the excellent work!

  41. rumble.com app

    This post covered all the right points. Thanks for making it so engaging!

  42. Lowes.com/survey

    At Lowe’s, we believe that your voice matters. We would love to hear from you if you have lately bought any tools, supplies for home renovation, or gardening necessities! Take a moment to complete our short and simple survey at Lowes.com/survey to provide us with your ideas and experiences.

  43. H&R Block login

    H&R Block provides an exceptionally easy-to-use product to prepare returns for both federal and state taxes. Go to H&R Block login and use the person icon in the upper right-hand corner to sign in or create a new account.

  44. cash app taxes

    Cash App Taxes, formerly known as credit Karma tax, is a very fast, easy and 100% free way to file federal and state taxes. Make sure you’re logging in through the cash app taxes website or mobile app.

  45. installturbotax.com

    To ensure a seamless installation and use of TurboTax, it is critical to meet its fundamental prerequisites. If you wish to use the most recent version of Turbotax, go to installturbotax.com today.

  46. installturbotax.com

    Are you ready to simplify your tax filing experience? Our TurboTax website is designed to provide you with all the essential knowledge you need to download, install, and activate TurboTax seamlessly via installturbotax.com.

  47. installturbotax.com

    Many people are often confused about how to install TurboTax after purchasing it. But don’t worry—it’s simpler than it seems! To install TurboTax with a 16-digit license code, visit InstallTurboTax.com, sign in or create an account, enter your 16-digit license code (XXXX-XXXX-XXXX-XXXX), and download the software. Once the installation is complete, activate TurboTax by entering the same license code when prompted.

  48. installturbotax.com

    Looking to install TurboTax for your tax preparation? InstallTurboTax.com provides all the resources you need to download, install, and set up TurboTax 2024 software on your PC or Mac. Simply enter your Turbotax license code, and with a user-friendly interface, TurboTax helps simplify the tax filing process, making it easy to manage your returns, calculate deductions, and submit forms electronically.

  49. TaxSlayer

    TaxSlayer is a trusted online tax preparation platform designed for easy tax filing, account management, and financial organization. Taxpayers can file federal and state taxes, receive IRS e-filing support, and maximize refunds using various tools. With straightforward account access through theTaxSlayer, users can manage tax filing quickly, meeting all requirements with just a few clicks.

  50. TaxSlayer pro

    Our platform is made to make tax preparation easier for you and to help you save time and energy. Put your trust in the taxslayerpro account for all of your filing requirements. You can have confidence knowing that your private data is secure. Create a more efficient tax preparation procedure by using TaxSlayer pro right now.

  51. Installturbotax.com 2024

    To ensure a seamless installation and use of TurboTax, it is critical to meet its fundamental prerequisites. If you wish to use the most recent version of Turbotax, go to Installturbotax.com 2024 today.

  52. microsoft.com/link

    Microsoft.com/link, offering a streamlined way to connect and manage your Microsoft accounts and services. This guide will walk you through the process, highlighting the key benefits and steps to get started.

  53. installturbotax.com

    TurboTax 2024 is a tax filing software that helps in filing individual and business tax returns in a simple and accurate manner. To download and install it, you can download the software by visiting installturbotax.com.

  54. insurance quotes

    By providing access to competitive quotes from various insurers, our website helps users find the best rates and coverage options to suit their needs and budget. providing access to competitive quotes from various insurers, our website insurance quotes helps users find the best rates and coverage options to suit their needs and budget.

  55. iforgot.apple.com

    Amazing content as always! I love how thorough and well-researched your posts are. You really go the extra mile to make things easy for your readers. Keep up the great work!

  56. iforgot.apple.com website

    This is exactly what I needed today! Your writing has such clarity. Thank you for making learning so accessible.

  57. 123 hp com setup

    Thanks for sharing this information! I was stuck setting up my HP printer, but your guide and the 123 HP com setup made it a breeze!

  58. 123 hp com setup

    Your post was exactly what I needed, and I’m thankful for the clear instructions. For anyone setting up HP printers, don’t forget to use 123 hp com setup for additional support.

  59. 123 hp com setup

    I love how straightforward your guide is. When combined with the instructions from 123 hp com setup, even complex printer setups are manageable.

  60. mcdvoice.com/survey

    I appreciate the time and effort you put into this post. It was very informative and well-written.

  61. tv.youtube.com/start

    Thanks for sharing your experience, it makes everything so much more relatable.

  62. mcdvoice.com survey

    “Thanks for writing this! Your insights are always so helpful. On a different note, McDonald’s fans can use the mcdvoice.com survey to give feedback and earn rewards!”

  63. rice purity test

    Thanks for the detailed insights. Your blog feels as revealing as a Rice Purity Test score!

  64. mcdvoice.com survey

    Awesome insights here! It’s inspiring to see dedication to improvement, similar to how McDonald’s uses the mcdvoice.com survey to gather customer feedback for growth.

  65. rumble.com/pair

    This insight is truly eye opening.

  66. iforgot apple

    Thank you for breaking down this complex subject into something so easy to understand.

  67. mcdvoice.com/survey

    You’ve really simplified a complicated topic. Kudos for making it so accessible.

  68. lowes.com/survey

    Your writing is inspiring! I’m so grateful for blogs like this. Similar to my experience with lowes.com/survey, it’s great to feel appreciated in any space.

  69. tellculvers.com/survey

    Thanks for sharing this! I always find value here. By the way, tellculvers.com/survey is an excellent way to give feedback and enjoy perks.

  70. tellculvers.com/survey

    Your blog post made my day—thank you so much for sharing! Speaking of great experiences, don’t forget to visit tellculvers.com/survey to let Culver’s know about their service. They truly care about customer input!

  71. Spotify.com pair

    Such an informative post—thanks a lot! It pairs wonderfully with some lo-fi beats I found on Spotify.com pair Perfect for focusing!

  72. tv.youtube.com/start

    Thank you for sharing this! I didn’t realize how simple it was to navigate tv.youtube.com/start until I read your blog.

  73. Disneyplus.com/begin

    Thanks for sharing this helpful post! If you’re a Disney movie and show fan, don’t miss out on the amazing experience at disneyplus.com/begin.

  74. tv.youtube.com/start

    Thanks for the detailed breakdown in your post! It’s been super helpful as I transition to streaming services. I recently got started with tv.youtube.com/start, and it’s been such a seamless experience.

  75. disneyplus.com/begin

    This blog was a great read! I truly appreciate the details you provided. Speaking of great content, have you tried disneyplus.com/begin? It’s the best place for Disney lovers!

  76. been verified

    This post is very useful! I appreciate the breakdown, and I can vouch for Been Verified’s accuracy in searches.

  77. disneyplus.com/begin

    Thank you for this helpful post! It’s always nice to find quality information. Speaking of great experiences, I just activated my Disney+ account at disneyplus.com/begin, and it’s been amazing!

  78. disneyplus.com/begin

    What an incredible article! I really appreciate the effort you put into this. And if you love Disney, I just activated my subscription through disneyplus.com/begin—highly recommend it!

  79. disneyplus.com begin

    Just subscribed to disneyplus.com begin, and I’m beyond thankful for all the amazing content. So many options to choose from!

  80. disneyplus.com/begin

    Thank you for sharing this! I always learn something new from your posts. On a side note, I’ve been enjoying Disney+ a lot—such a great streaming service! You can get started at disneyplus.com/begin.

  81. tv.youtube.com/start

    Thanks for sharing this! Streaming services keep evolving, and I’m excited to explore tv.youtube.com/start after reading your blog.

  82. rumble.com/pair

    I can’t express how grateful I am for this post! It’s not every day you come across such valuable information. Also, I discovered some similar content on rumble.com/pair that might interest others.

  83. liteblue portal

    Thank you for this wonderful article! Your content is always insightful and easy to follow. The liteblue portal is a lifesaver for postal employees, and your blog is a great resource for knowledge seekers. Keep up the amazing work!

  84. disneyplus.com begin

    I’m so grateful for this article! disneyplus.com begin continues to impress me with its selection, and your insights helped me discover even more to watch. Thanks again!

Leave a Reply